Pallywood. It’s undeniable that defenders of Israel often have the need to try and hurt others. As most bullies they have some intuitive understanding of what hurts. Maybe because they were hurt so often in their childhood they know first hand what works and what doesn’t work. A rather incisive and painful slash at someone is to deny that person’s experience.
Survivors of sexual abuse will often report that not being believed by others, sometimes not even their own mother ‘you must have dreamed that the babysitter did this to you’, was worse than the sexual abuse itself. What they also often need to hear, usually repeatedly and very loud and clear, is that they are not the guilty party, they did not trigger the sexual abuse, they did not invite it. If you want to throw oil or kerosine on the flames of trauma simply suggest that the victims brought it upon themselves. I’ve seen very intelligent and kind-natured clients drift towards drugs and severe forms of self-sabotage because their experiences were repeatedly denied and reframed disingenuously.
This is exactly what Israel’s online bully gang is doing by using the term Pallywood. They know precisely what they are doing and don’t believe for a second that the Palestinians are staging their own suffering. In many cases they – willfully and comfortably – avoid thoroughly researched history books and perhaps genuinely believe that the Palestinians are the quintessential driver of all hostilities, but they do know that many Palestinians are suffering in the worst ways imaginable. Yet they deliberately continue to label obvious evidence of human agony as Pallywood.
It helps to not feel guilt, it helps to counter any criticism of Israel, and, most of all, it’s easy. You may have noticed that defenders of Israel don’t put effort into their propaganda. This could be laziness, but it’s also because it’s hard to consistently come up with details to embellish a lie. A simple lie is much more effective than a complicated one.
Pallywood may first remind you of Hollywood, but it should also remind you of Bollywood. There is fundamental racism lurking under the word. It’s the suggestion that Pallywood videos are as boring, as poorly executed and as repetitive as all those Indian movies only Indians can sit through. It’s become clear to many of you how much disdain Israeli society has for other cultures. That they can always drag some local Uncle Tom along for a photo op is never very convincing.
It’s also easy to spot that even the angriest Pro-Palestinian voices tend to be driven by love and a strong reflex to protect the weak. Yes, some point out that pro-Palestinians identify so much with the underdog, because they themselves were hurt at some point and don’t want others to be hurt. If, as in a thought experiment, we accept this theory, we can then say that pro-Israeli voices act so hysterically because of hurts in their own past. The difference is in the reaction. Pro-Palestinian: I am hurt, I don’t want others to hurt. Pro-Israeli: I deny that I was ever hurt and distract myself from my own personal traumas by trying to victimize and hurt others. Pro-Palestinians are more courageous and embrace the hurt, pro-Israelis deny the hurt and want others to suffer, others who are different from them, others who they know very little about.
There is namely nothing benign about throwing around the term Pallywood. If they wanted to expose the Palestinians for faking their hell, they could do it with facts, but they can’t. They have to keep it simple and primitive and purely emotional. All they can do is abuse the behind the scenes images of a war movie filmed in Lebanon some time ago to confuse people who are not familiar with what has been happening in this region of the world.
It’s been an exceptionally bad year for pro-Israel propaganda.
As a test I once took a tweet that went: ‘Pallywood productions and its distributors hurt the Palestinian cause so much’ and changed it to ‘Izrawood productions and its distributors hurt Israel so much.’ This immediately trigged buckets of anger, because they know their own tactic, they know exactly how malignant the term Pallywood is.
And what must be hurting the most, is that it hasn’t worked. Israel’s pointless slaughter of the Palestinians cannot be covered up by using such a lame tactic.
They know that too and what they hope for is hurting a few folks, as a revenge for living in a world they assume believes something bad never happened to Israelis. They think we deny their reality and so they want to deny the reality of the Palestinians. We don’t deny their reality, we just don’t accept their lies. Yes, if you scrape away the pathological lies, some bad stuff has happened to Israelis. It was at times horrible, but not as perversely and Baroque style horrible as Izrawood would like you to believe and nothing of it offers a justification to murder more than 100,000 people (see the Lancet).
But Israeli propaganda doesn’t have to hurt anyone. It’s an entirely toothless worn out and obese attack dog. A bit annoying, but peeing itself by trying to bark too loudly for its own good.
